Top Tips for Choosing the Right Roofer in Scotland

Your roof takes a constant beating from Scottish weather — wind, rain, frost, the lot.

So when you need roof repairs, replacement or maintenance, choosing the right roofing contractor really matters.

The wrong choice can mean poor workmanship, unnecessary delays and paying twice to fix mistakes.

And let’s be honest — telling a good roofer from a bad one isn’t always easy.

Here’s a simple, no-nonsense guide to help you choose a trusted local roofer with confidence.

1. Look for real roofing experience (not just good marketing)

Roofing is a trade learned on the tools — not in a brochure.

Ask:

• How long have you been roofing?

• What roof types do you specialise in (slate, tile, flat, lead work)?

• Will it be yourself doing the work, your team or do you sub-contract? What credentials and experience do they have?

• Can you show recent local jobs?

Experience with your specific roof type matters far more than a smart van or flashy branding. Small local roofers are often just as skilled — sometimes more so — than large companies with big overheads. And you might not have head or them, because they don't really need to advertise for work.

2. Check reviews and local reputation

Search their name online and look for consistent feedback on:

• quality of work

• reliability

• communication

• aftercare

Also ask neighbours or local Facebook groups. Word of mouth still beats adverts.

Tip: if a contractor is free to start immediately on a large job, there’s often a reason. Good roofers are usually booked ahead - sometimes months and months ahead.

3. Get clear written quotes (not vague prices)

Always get at least three written estimates.

A proper roofing quote should include:

• exact scope of work

• materials being used

• labour costs

• timescales

• warranties

• payment schedule

If it’s unclear or vague - walk away.

Cheapest isn’t always best — but the most expensive doesn’t guarantee quality either. Detail and transparency are what matter.

4. Be sensible with payments

Avoid paying everything upfront.

Normal UK practice is:

• small deposit

• stage payments

• balance on completion

For bigger jobs, consider holding back a small retention until you’re satisfied.

If someone demands full payment before starting the work, that’s a red flag.

5. Check warranties and guarantees

A reputable roofing contractor should offer:

• manufacturer warranties on materials

• a workmanship guarantee

Get it in writing. Verbal promises don’t count.

6. Plan around Scottish weather

Roofing work depends on dry, safe conditions.

Delays happen — that’s normal and unfortunately, expected.

Anyone rushing work through heavy rain or high winds isn’t protecting your home properly. Better slower and right than quick and leaky.

Still unsure about the work?

Get back intouch with your contractor and explain your concerns. Give them a chance to fix the issue. If it issue remains unresolved, contact them again. If they cannot repair it properly, will they provide a (partial) refund or pay for another contractor to rectify the work?

If they refuse, or their work remains sub-standard, contact trading standards or seek legal advice. If you’re concerned about workmanship or want an impartial second opinion, an independent roof survey can help. Companies like Assure Roof Surveys provide roof inspections and professional reports with no repair or sales bias — just factual findings. Useful for peace of mind, disputes or property purchases.

Quick checklist

Before hiring a roofer:

✔ Experienced with your roof type✔ Good local reputation✔ Detailed written quote✔ Fair payment terms✔ Clear warranty✔ No pressure selling

Take your time. A properly installed roof should last decades — it’s worth choosing carefully.